Darwin, That Genius, Was Responsible for Hitler, Stalin, and Pol Pot

Charles Darwin in 1881

Photo by Colin Purrington/Elliott & Fry Studio/Wikimedia Commons.

At my conservative private school in the South, evolution was the science that dare not speak its name. My sixth grade biology teacher told us it was ?just a theory that you don?t have to believe.? In 10^th grade, a classmate skipped a lecture on natural selection because, in her words, ?I don?t want to believe we come from monkeys.? One teacher had a book in the back of her classroom entitled A Complete History of the Human Race. It began with Adam and Eve. These people viewed Darwin as a kind of biologist Iago, whispering lies into our ears and coaxing us toward damnation. Science was sinful; religion (specifically, evangelical Baptism) was truth. Ignore the Neanderthal skeleton behind the curtain.

I?ve been living in progressive Washington, D.C. for three years now, but I still get a bit defensive when evolution comes up for discussion?particularly when the instigator is Paul Johnson, the conservative, family-values-promoting British intellectual. Johnson is a firm opponent of modernism in all its forms; he has spoken out against divorce, liberation theology, unions, atheism, the Enlightenment, and even the Beatles. He?s on the record attacking Richard Dawkins and Darwinist ?fundamentalists,? labeling them ?bigots? who practice an ?extreme form of atheism.?

So why in the world would he write a mini-biography of Darwin with the glowing subtitle ?portrait of a genius??

To give Johnson the benefit of the doubt, there is certainly a need for a concise book like this. The definitive biography of Darwin is nearly 900 pages; another two-volume work stretches past the 1,200 mark. Johnson?s book comes in at 151 pages, with large text and generous line spacing. If Johnson had gotten the book right?if he had written with objectivity, captured the essence of evolution by natural selection, painted a picture of Darwin as a gentleman and a scientist?he could have written the Darwin biography for everybody.

But he didn?t get it right. He got it horribly, almost comically wrong. As a biographical sketch, Darwin: Portrait of a Genius is brisk and sufficient. But as an exploration of Darwin?s theory and its effect on the world, the book feels like Johnson?s weird, bitter vendetta against a scientist who was always more interested in mollusks than men.

The problems begin more than halfway through the book, so if you?re looking for an overview of Darwin?s lineage and early life, I suggest you stop immediately after Johnson?s (admittedly engaging) discussion of the world?s reaction to The Origin of Species. Johnson captures the gentle rhythms of Darwin?s early life fairly well: his brilliant, loving family, his rich education, his Beagle voyage to the Galapagos Islands and resulting eureka moment. ?Was ever a scientist more fortunate or more happy?? Johnson ruminates, and we are tempted to agree. Darwin?s wife, we are told, was ?clever, educated, equable, hardworking, industrious, economical, and, not least, sensitive,? his father a wealthy ?genius,? his children loving. Throughout his life, Darwin elicited respect from the scientific community and from Britons at large; according to Johnson, he faced no serious public backlash from publishing Origin, though he feared one and probably delayed writing the book for decades for that reason.

Even Johnson?s overview of Darwin?s theory of evolution is clear, rich, and accurate. Darwin, of course, wasn?t the first to realize that species had evolved over time, but he perfected the theory by identifying natural selection as its main driver. He also explained and publicized evolution more effectively than his peers had done. Johnson explains that we remember Darwin, rather than Herbert Spencer or Alfred Russel Wallace, as the father of evolutionary theory in part because of Origin?s immense popular appeal, as well as Darwin?s ?exquisite tact? in downplaying the book?s real conclusion (the Bible is wrong).

Source: http://feeds.slate.com/click.phdo?i=0bc921a61d5cfe6acfc0074fb6bd3a4b

trayvon martin case affordable care act the line bobby brown arrested the happening jennifer lawrence black panthers